Piper PA 23 accident near Beaver Island, Michigan, December 31, 2018
On December 31, 2018, a 1956 Piper PA 23, registered N2146P, was destroyed in an accident during initial climb near Beaver Island, Michigan (Beaver Island airport). It was a personal flight under general aviation rules (Part 91). 1 person was killed. The weather was visual conditions (good weather).
The NTSB's probable cause their words, unchanged
The pilot's failure to maintain a positive rate of climb after takeoff which resulted in an impact with trees and terrain. Contributing to the accident was the pilot's inability to see a visible horizon due to the dark night lighting conditions and limited ground lights in the vicinity of the airport.
Source: NTSB aviation accident database, copy made November 2, 2026. Docket and reports at the NTSB.
What the record shows
- Date
- December 31, 2018 · cases in 2018
- Place
- Beaver Island, Michigan · Beaver Island · cases near this airport · map
- Type
- Accident
- Injuries
- 1 person was killed.
- Weather
- visual conditions (good weather)
- Aircraft
- Piper PA 23 Undesignat, built 1956 · all PA 23s on the register
- Registration
- N2146P · no longer on the register · serial 23-748
- Damage
- Destroyed
- Flight
- Personal flight · general aviation rules (Part 91)
The NTSB's narrative final · quoted from the NTSB record
The instrument, multi-engine rated private pilot was departing into dark night visual meteorological conditions at the time of the accident. The airport was located in an area with minimal ground lighting with no discernable horizon visible after takeoff. Witnesses heard the airplane take off toward the west and subsequently turn to the north. They described the sound of the engines as "very loud." One witness added that the engines seemed to be operating normally. Another witness noted that the sound changed to a lower pitch similar to when a pilot transitions to climb power after takeoff. The sound ended abruptly when the airplane impacted a wooded area about 1/3 mile from the airport on a north-northeasterly heading. Examination of the airframe and engines did not reveal any anomalies consistent with a preimpact failure or malfunction. It is possible that the pilot experienced some level spatial disorientation which led to a loss of control and impact with the trees and terrain. However, it is also possible that the pilot became distracted configuring the airplane for climb during the initial turn after takeoff which led to the airplane entering an inadvertent descent and controlled flight into terrain. This scenario is consistent with the witness statement noting a transition to climb power immediately after takeoff. In addition, the earwitness reports did not describe a typical loss-of-control event. The lack of a visible horizon due to the dark night lighting conditions and lack of ground lights in the vicinity of the airport would have contributed to either scenario.
The complete narrative as the NTSB published it. The NTSB's docket holds the report as a PDF and any photographs, statements and other documents from the investigation.
The factual record from the NTSB's investigation tables, in plain English
What happened, in order
- Loss of visual reference during initial climb
- Unknown or undetermined during initial climb defining event
- Altitude deviation during initial climb
- Collision with terrain or object (not controlled flight into terrain) during initial climb
The NTSB's findings
- cause Aircraft › Aircraft oper/perf/capability › Performance/control parameters › Climb rate › Not attained/maintained
- cause Personnel issues › Task performance › Use of equip/info › (general) › Pilot
- factor Environmental issues › Conditions/weather/phenomena › Light condition › Dark › Effect on personnel
Pilot
- Certificate: private
- Ratings: multi-engine land; single-engine land; instrument: airplane
- Flight time: 5,468 hours in all
- Medical certificate: Class 3 (with waivers/limitations)
- Seat: left
- Injury: fatal
The aircraft
- Airframe total time: 8,809 hours
- Last inspection: annual inspection, September 27, 2018
- Maximum gross weight: 3,501 lb
- Seats: 4
- Landing gear: retractable
- Engine 1: Lycoming O-360-A1D (piston); 4,223 hours total
- Engine 2: Lycoming O-360-A1D (piston); 4,385 hours total
The flight
- Departed from: SJX Beaver Island MI
- Destination: FPK Charlotte MI
- Flight plan: none
- Runway 27, 4,299 ft by 75 ft
Weather at the time
- Light: night, dark
- Wind: from 240° at 8 knots, gusting 15
- Visibility: 10 statute miles
- Sky: broken clouds at 2,500 ft
- Temperature: 34°F (1°C), dew point 27°F (-3°C)
- Altimeter: 29.92 inHg
Injuries
| Fatal | Serious | Minor | None | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flight crew | 1 |
Photographs from the investigation 19 pictures from the NTSB's docket, as the NTSB released them
Photo 1 – Accident Site (Island Airways Photo)
Photo 2 – Accident Site (Island Airways Photo)
Photo 3 – Accident Site (Island Airways Photo)
Photo 4 – Accident Site (Island Airways Photo)
Photo 5 – Accident Site (Island Airways Photo)
Photo 6 – Accident Site (Island Airways Photo)
Photo 7 – Airframe Layout (Piper Photo)
Photo 8 – Center Fuselage / Cabin (NTSB Photo)
Photo 9 – Forward Fuselage / Cockpit (NTSB Photo)
Photo 10 – Instrument Panel / Throttle Quadrant (NTSB Photo)
Photo 11 – Left Wing (NTSB Photo)
Photo 12 – Right Wing (NTSB Photo)
Photo 13 – Vertical Stabilizer (NTSB Photo)
Photo 14 – Aft Fuselage / Horizontal Stabilizers (NTSB Photo)
Photo 15 – Left Engine (NTSB Photo)
Photo 16 – Left Propeller (NTSB Photo)
Photo 17 – Left Propeller (NTSB Photo)
Photo 18 – Right Engine (Lycoming Photo)
Photo 19 – Right Propeller (NTSB Photo)The NTSB's photographs with the NTSB's captions, at screen size. Open a picture to see it full size or to report one that should not be shown.
Documents from the investigation the NTSB's docket: the evidence folder behind the report
6 documents, released by the NTSB on January 17, 2020. View them here, or download them; the NTSB redacts some personal details before release, and this site shows the NTSB's own titles rather than its file names.
| # | Document | What it is | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Accident Site Diagram | PDF, 2 pages · our copy | View Download |
| 2 | Witness Statements | PDF, 4 pages · our copy | View Download |
| 3 | Conversation Summary -- Pilot's Family | PDF, 1 page · our copy | View Download |
| 4 | Report Photos | PDF, 19 pages · our copy | View Download |
| 5 | Airplane Examination Summary | PDF, 6 pages · our copy | View Download |
| 6 | FAA Aviation Physiology -- Spatial Disorientation | PDF, 6 pages · our copy | View Download |
Connections how this case links to the rest of the register
- N2146P: not on the register today · the record of its deregistration
- Piper PA-23 Apache and Aztec 1,316 registered today · the model family and its accident history
- Piper 44,854 aircraft on the register
- Engine: Lycoming O-360-A1D 1,056 aircraft carry this series today · as the NTSB recorded it
- Engine: Lycoming O-360-A1D 1,056 aircraft carry this series today · as the NTSB recorded it
- Beaver Island Airport · nearest airport
- Fitch H Beach Airport · bound for
- Accidents and incidents in Michigan 2,107 since 1982 · 230 in the last ten years
- Michigan 7,238 aircraft registered
The whole map of how records connect · these connections as data: /graph/accident/CEN19LA051.json.
The bigger picture in Aviation Analytics: accidents over time since 1982, by model, by phase of flight and conditions, by place and on the map.
Everything on this page comes from the NTSB's public records. The narrative, probable cause and findings are the NTSB's own words; the coded tables behind the report are written out in plain English, with pilots' ages, home towns and medical details left out. The documents and photographs are the NTSB's docket, shown as the NTSB released them. This site's own text does not name anyone involved, its policy at this time. A preliminary report can change; the final report usually follows one to two years later, and the page is refreshed when it does.