The U.S. aircraft register, updated daily
Accidents · NTSB CEN09MA142 · Final report

Aerospatiale Alenia ATR 42-320 accident near Lubbock, Texas, January 27, 2009

On January 27, 2009 at about 10:37 am local time, a Aerospatiale Alenia ATR 42-320, registered N902FX, was substantially damaged in an accident during approach (IFR initial approach) near Lubbock, Texas (Lubbock Preston Smith airport). It was flown under scheduled airline rules (Part 121). 1 person was seriously injured and 1 person had minor injuries. The weather was instrument conditions (cloud, fog or low visibility).

The NTSB's probable cause their words, unchanged

The flight crew's failure to monitor and maintain a minimum safe airspeed while executing an instrument approach in icing conditions, which resulted in an aerodynamic stall at low altitude. Contributing to the accident were 1) the flight crew's failure to follow published standard operating procedures in response to a flap anomaly, 2) the captain's decision to continue with the unstabilized approach, 3) the flight crew's poor crew resource management, and 4) fatigue due to the time of day in which the accident occurred and a cumulative sleep debt, which likely impaired the captain's performance.

Source: NTSB aviation accident database, copy made November 2, 2026. Docket and reports at the NTSB.

What the record shows

Date
January 27, 2009 · about 10:37 am local time · cases in 2009
Place
Lubbock, Texas · Lubbock Preston Smith · cases near this airport · map
Type
Accident
Injuries
1 person was seriously injured and 1 person had minor injuries.
Weather
instrument conditions (cloud, fog or low visibility)
Aircraft
Aerospatiale Alenia ATR 42-320
Registration
N902FX · no longer on the register · serial 325
Damage
Substantial damage
Flight
Flight · scheduled airline rules (Part 121)

The NTSB's narrative final · quoted from the NTSB record

The Safety Board’s full report is available at http://www.ntsb.gov/Publictn/A_Acc1.htm. The Aircraft Accident Report number is NTSB/AAR-11/02. On January 27, 2009, about 0437 central standard time, an Avions de Transport Régional Aerospatiale Alenia ATR 42 320, N902FX, operating as Empire Airlines flight 8284, was on an instrument approach when it crashed short of the runway at Lubbock Preston Smith International Airport, Lubbock, Texas. The captain sustained serious injuries, and the first officer sustained minor injuries. The airplane was substantially damaged. The airplane was registered to Federal Express Corporation and operated by Empire Airlines, Inc., as a 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 121 supplemental cargo flight. The flight departed from Fort Worth Alliance Airport, Fort Worth, Texas, about 0313. Instrument meteorological conditions prevailed, and an instrument flight rules flight plan was filed.

The complete narrative as the NTSB published it. The NTSB's docket holds the report as a PDF and any photographs, statements and other documents from the investigation.

The factual record from the NTSB's investigation tables, in plain English

What happened, in order

  1. Collision with terrain or object (not controlled flight into terrain) during approach (IFR final approach)
  2. Aerodynamic stall/spin during approach (IFR initial approach) defining event

The NTSB's findings

  • cause Personnel issues › Task performance › Use of equip/info › Aircraft control › Flight crew
  • cause Aircraft › Aircraft oper/perf/capability › Performance/control parameters › Airspeed › Not attained/maintained
  • Environmental issues › Conditions/weather/phenomena › Ceiling/visibility/precip › Freezing rain/sleet › Effect on equipment
  • factor Personnel issues › Action/decision › Action › Incorrect action performance › Pilot
  • factor Personnel issues › Action/decision › Info processing/decision › (general) › Flight crew
  • factor Personnel issues › Physical › Alertness/Fatigue › Lack of sleep › Pilot
  • factor Personnel issues › Physical › Alertness/Fatigue › Circadian rhythms or jetlag › Pilot
  • factor Personnel issues › Task performance › Communication (personnel) › CRM/MRM techniques › Flight crew
  • Organizational issues › Management › Communication (organizational) › Between groups/organizations › Emergency services
  • Environmental issues › Operating environment › Airport facilities/design › (general) › Effect on operation

Pilot

  • Certificate: airline transport pilot, commercial pilot
  • Ratings: multi-engine land; single-engine land; instrument: airplane
  • Flight time: 13,200 hours in all
  • Last flight review: July 5, 2008
  • Medical certificate: Class 1 (with waivers/limitations)
  • Seat: left
  • Injury: serious injuries

Co-pilot

  • Certificate: flight instructor, commercial pilot
  • Ratings: multi-engine land; single-engine land; instructor: airplane multi-engine; instructor: airplane single-engine; instrument: airplane
  • Flight time: 2,000 hours in all
  • Medical certificate: Class 1 (without waivers/limitations)
  • Seat: rgt
  • Injury: minor injuries

The aircraft

  • Airframe total time: 29,767.9 hours
  • Last inspection: continuous airworthiness programme, January 9, 2009
  • Maximum gross weight: 37,258 lb
  • Landing gear: retractable
  • Engine 1: Pratt and Whitney Canada PW 121 (turboprop); 0 hours total
  • Engine 2: Pratt and Whitney Canada PW 121 (turboprop); 0 hours total
  • Fire on the ground
  • Operator: Empire Airlines

The flight

  • Departed from: AFW Fort Worth TX at 9:19 am
  • Destination: LBB Lubbock TX
  • Flight plan: IFR
  • Runway 17R, 11,500 ft by 150 ft
  • A second pilot was aboard

Weather at the time

  • Light: night, dark
  • Wind: from 350° at 10 knots
  • Visibility: 2 statute miles
  • Sky: overcast at 500 ft
  • Temperature: 46°F (8°C), dew point 48°F (9°C)
  • Altimeter: 30.21 inHg
  • Observation at 10:15 am from LBB

Injuries

FatalSeriousMinorNone
Flight crew11

Documents from the investigation the NTSB's docket: the evidence folder behind the report

140 documents, released by the NTSB on September 22, 2009. View them here, or download them; the NTSB redacts some personal details before release, and this site shows the NTSB's own titles rather than its file names.

#DocumentWhat it is
1 Order of Hearing: 1A PDF, 1 page View Download
2 Notice of Designation of Chairman of Board of Inquiry: 1B PDF, 1 page View Download
3 Designation of Hearing Officer: 1C PDF, 1 page View Download
4 Designation of Parties to the Hearing: 1D PDF, 1 page View Download
5 Notice of Hearing: 1E PDF, 1 page View Download
6 Pilot/operator Aircraft Accident Report, NTSB Form 6120.1 PDF, 11 pages View Download
7 Operations 2A - Factual Report of Group Chairman PDF, 46 pages View Download
8 Operations 2B - Flight Crew Training Events Summary and Issued Documents PDF, 8 pages View Download
9 Operations 2C - Flight Crew Flight Time and Duty Record PDF, 7 pages View Download
10 Operations 2D - Empire Airlines January 2009 Atr Trip Pairings PDF, 3 pages View Download
11 Operations 2E - Witness Statements (Including Empire Dispatch Log Information) PDF, 7 pages View Download
12 Operations 2F - Interview Summaries of Captain Rodney Holberton PDF, 19 pages View Download
13 Operations 2G - Interview Summaries of First Officer Heather Cornell PDF, 17 pages View Download
14 Operations 2H - Interview Summaries of Empire Airlines Dispatch Personnel PDF, 9 pages View Download
15 Operations 2I - Interview Summaries of FAA Poi and Assistant Poi PDF, 6 pages View Download
16 Operations 2J - Interview Summaries of Director of Operations and Chief Pilot PDF, 8 pages View Download
17 Operations 2K - Interview Summaries of Empire Training Manager and Check Airmen PDF, 12 pages View Download
18 Operations 2L - Interview Summaries of Empire Airlines Director of Safety and Compliance PDF, 11 pages View Download
19 Operations 2M - Interview Summaries of Empire Airlines Technical Publications Personnel PDF, 3 pages View Download
20 Operations 2N - Interview Summaries of Pilots Previously Paired with the Accident Crew PDF, 18 pages View Download
21 Operations 2O - Interview Summaries of Flight Safety International Personnel PDF, 27 pages View Download
22 Memorandum for Record: Witness Statement and Interview Summary Changes/clarifications PDF, 2 pages View Download
23 Operations 2P - Weight and Balance Information PDF, 4 pages View Download
24 Operations 2Q - Part 121 Flight Release and Weather (Maf to Elp) PDF, 14 pages View Download
25 Operations 2R - Part 91 Flight Release and Weather (Elp to Afw) Note: Example, Not Original PDF, 14 pages View Download
26 Operations 2S - Part 121 Flight Release and Weather (Afw to Lbb) PDF, 17 pages View Download
27 Operations 2T - Lbb Metars PDF, 5 pages View Download
28 Operations 2U - Flight Profiles and Briefings PDF, 5 pages View Download
29 Operations 2V - Airport and Approach Information (Lbb) PDF, 4 pages View Download
30 Operations 2W - Told Card, Flight Data Card, and F/o Notes PDF, 5 pages View Download
31 Operations 2X - Atr 42 Normal Checklist PDF, 4 pages View Download
32 Operations 2Y - Airspeed Bug Information PDF, 6 pages View Download
33 Operations 2Z - Excerpts from Empire Atr 42 Quick Reference Handbook (QRH) PDF, 10 pages View Download
34 Operations 2AA - Excerpts from Atr 42 Airplane Flight Manual (AFM) PDF, 13 pages View Download
35 Operations 2BB - Excerpt from Empire General Operations Manual (Gom), Icing PDF, 3 pages View Download
36 Operations 2CC - Excerpts from Empire Airlines Atr 42 Pilot Handbook (Adverse Weather) PDF, 16 pages View Download
37 Operations 2DD - Empire Operations Specifications (A009) PDF, 3 pages View Download
38 Operations 2EE - List of Examined/recovered Cockpit Items and Issued Documents PDF, 12 pages View Download
39 Operations 2FF - Excerpt from Empire Airlines Aircraft Deicing Program (Adp) PDF, 5 pages View Download
40 Operations 2GG - Excerpts from Empire Airlines Gom (Flight Following Procedures) PDF, 4 pages View Download
41 Operations 2HH - Excerpts from Empire Airlines Gom (Braking Action Reports) PDF, 3 pages View Download
42 Operations 2II - Excerpts from Empire Airlines Gom (Takeoffs and Landings by First Officer) PDF, 3 pages View Download
43 Operations 2JJ - Excerpts from Empire Airlines Gom (Emergency Operations) PDF, 4 pages View Download
44 Operations 2KK - Excerpts from Empire Gom (Component Failure/captain's Responsibility) PDF, 4 pages View Download
45 Operations 2LL - Empire Airlines Stabilized Approach Criteria PDF, 5 pages View Download
46 Operations 2MM - Excerpts from Atr 42 FCOM (Stall Alert and Activation) PDF, 3 pages View Download
47 Operations 2NN - Excerpts from Atr 42 FCOM (Air Data System) PDF, 3 pages View Download
48 Operations 2OO - Excerpts from Atr 42 FCOM (Fast/slow Indicator) PDF, 4 pages View Download
49 Operations 2PP - Excerpts from Atr 42 FCOM (Anti Icing Advisory System) PDF, 4 pages View Download
50 Operations 2QQ - Schematic of Atr 42 Flap System PDF, 3 pages View Download
51 Operations 2RR - Excerpts from Empire Airlines Gom (C208 Icing Restrictions) PDF, 3 pages View Download
52 Operations 2SS - Atr Winter Operations Reminder (December 6, 2002) PDF, 4 pages View Download
53 Operations 2TT - Atr Letter to EASA (Freezing Drizzle/freezing Rain) February 12, 2009 PDF, 4 pages View Download
54 Operations 2UU - Empire Airlines Flight Operations Bulletin 09-04 (Icing/post Accident) PDF, 4 pages View Download
55 Operations 2VV - Excerpts from Atr 42 Pilot Handbook (Task Sharing/post Accident) PDF, 4 pages View Download
56 Operations 2WW - Empire Flight Information Bulletin 09-06 (Flaps Asymmetry/post Accident) PDF, 3 pages View Download
57 Operations 2XX - Excerpts from Empire Gom (Conduct of Non-revenue Flights/post Accident) PDF, 5 pages View Download
58 Operations 2YY - Excerpts from Empire Ftm (Pilot Ground Training and Atr Ground Training) PDF, 7 pages View Download
59 Operations 2ZZ - Atos System/subsystem/element Chart (Operations) PDF, 3 pages View Download
60 Operations 2AAA - Excerpts from Empire Operations Specifications (Training Organizations) PDF, 3 pages View Download
61 Operations 2BBB - Atr Cold Weather Operations Guide (Be Prepared for Icing) PDF, 78 pages View Download
62 Operations 2CCC - Empire Airlines Descent and Approach Awareness Procedure PDF, 3 pages View Download
63 Operations 2DDD - Empire Airlines Flight Profile and Briefing (Normal ILS Approach) PDF, 4 pages View Download
64 Operations 2EEE - Empire Airlines Atr Go Around Procedure PDF, 3 pages View Download
65 Operations 2FFF - Empire Airlines TAWS Procedures PDF, 4 pages View Download
66 Operations 2GGG - FAA Icing Fact Sheet PDF, 5 pages View Download
67 Operations 2JJJ - FAA Presentation - Icing Requirements and Guidance PDF, 16 pages View Download
68 Operations 2HHH - Open NTSB Icing Recommendations to FAA PDF, 46 pages View Download
69 Operations 2III - NTSB Icing Recommendations PDF, 149 pages View Download
70 Operations 2KKK - Empire QRH Excerpt PDF, 2 pages View Download
71 Operations 2LLL - Empire Airlines Gom Excerpt PDF, 2 pages View Download
72 Memorandum for the Record (Training Program and Manual Discrepancies) PDF, 2 pages View Download
73 ATC 3A - Factual Report of Group Chairman PDF, 10 pages View Download
74 ATC 3C - Lbb Atct Aircraft Accident Package PDF, 79 pages View Download
75 Meteorology 5A - Factual Report of Group Chairman PDF, 33 pages View Download
76 Meteorology 5B - Attachment 1 Weather Document and Klbb Observations PDF, 17 pages View Download
77 Meteorology 5C - Attachment 2 Cip Icing Severity PDF, 7 pages View Download
78 Meteorology 5D - Nws Awc Presentation PPT file Download
79 Survival Factors 6 - Factual Report of Group Chairman PDF, 24 pages View Download
80 Survival Factors 6 - Attachment 1 Arff Dispatch Logs PDF, 14 pages View Download
81 Survival Factors 6 - Attachment 2 Airfield Condition Logs PDF, 6 pages View Download
82 Survival Factors 6 - Attachment 3 Snow and Ice Event Logs PDF, 3 pages View Download
83 Survival Factors 6 - Attachment 4 Notice to Airman Lbb PDF, 9 pages View Download
84 Survival Factors 6 - Attachment 5 Airport Emergency Plan PDF, 29 pages View Download
85 Survival Factors 6 - Attachment 6 Snow and Ice Operations PDF, 7 pages View Download
86 Survival Factors 6 - Attachment 7 Hazmat Information & Notac PDF, 20 pages View Download
87 Airworthiness 7A - Factual Report of Group Chairman PDF, 53 pages View Download
88 Airworthiness 7 - Addendum 1 PDF, 5 pages View Download
89 Airworthiness 7- Addendum 2 PDF, 2 pages View Download
90 Airworthiness 7B- Attachment 1.1 Previous Accident PDF, 20 pages View Download
91 Airworthiness 7C- Attachment 1.2 History Prior to Purchase PDF, 5 pages View Download
92 Airworthiness 7D - Attachment 1.3 Inspection Status PDF, 8 pages View Download
93 Airworthiness 7E - Attachment 1.4 Daily Flight Logs PDF, 7 pages View Download
94 Airworthiness 7F- Attachment 1.5 Cargo Conversion STC FAA Form 337 PDF, 4 pages View Download
95 Airworthiness 7G - Attachment 1.6 Flap History PDF, 18 pages View Download
96 Attachment 7H - Attachment 1.7 Hydraulic System PDF, 18 pages View Download
97 Airworthiness 7I - Attachment 2.1 Operations Manual Excerpt PDF, 42 pages View Download
98 Airworthiness 7J - Attachment 2.2 Record of Conversation Director of Maintenance PDF, 3 pages View Download
99 Airworthiness 7K - Attachment 2.3 FAA Inspector Interviews PDF, 8 pages View Download
100 Airworthiness 7L - Attachment 3.1 Airport Diagram PDF, 3 pages View Download
101 Airworthiness 7M - Attachment 3.2 Cockpit Documentation PDF, 8 pages View Download
102 Airworthiness 7N - Attachment 3.3 Fbi Overall Mapping PDF, 3 pages View Download
103 Airworthiness 7O - Attachment 4.1 Honeywell Testing PDF, 7 pages View Download
104 Airworthiness 7P - Attachment 4.2 FAR 25.699 and Jar 25.699 PDF, 5 pages View Download
105 Flight Data Recorder 10A - Specialist's Factual Report PDF, 19 pages View Download
106 Flight Data Recorder 10B - Attachment 1 - Tabular Data -entire Flight - (Csv Format) data file Download
107 Flight Data Recorder 10C - Attachment 2 - Tabular Data - Last 15 Minutes (Csv Format) data file Download
108 Cockpit Voice Recorder 12 - Factual Report of Group Chairman PDF, 26 pages View Download
109 Aircraft Performance 13 - Airplane Performance Study PDF, 20 pages View Download
110 Aircraft Performance 13 - Airplane Performance Study Errata PDF, 1 page View Download
111 Aircraft Performance 13 - Airplane Performance Study Addendum 1 PDF, 17 pages View Download
112 Aircraft Performance 13B - Atr Design Changes Since Roselawn PDF, 18 pages View Download
113 Aircraft Performance 13C - Atr Aircraft Performance Monitoring System PDF, 17 pages View Download
114 Aircraft Performance 13D - Atr Performance Analysis PDF, 18 pages View Download
115 Aircraft Performance 13E - Atr Flap and Stall Warning Systems PDF, 16 pages View Download
116 Aircraft Performance 13F - EASA Presentation on ATR-42 Certification PDF, 9 pages View Download
117 Aircraft Performance 13G - FAA Presentation - Transport Category Certification PDF, 10 pages View Download
118 Aircraft Performance 13H - FAA Presentation - Asias PDF, 11 pages View Download
119 Aircraft Performance 13I - FAA Presentation - Proposed Icing Envelope PDF, 12 pages View Download
120 Aircraft Performance 13J - FAA Presentation - National Simulator Program PDF, 6 pages View Download
121 Aircraft Performance 13K - FAA Pai Memo on Flap Asymmetry Indication PDF, 7 pages View Download
122 Human Performance 14A - Factual Report PDF, 9 pages View Download
123 Human Performance 14B - Empire Airlines Personnel Interviews PDF, 29 pages View Download
124 Materials Laboratory 15A - Factual Report 09-051 Annuciator Panel PDF, 4 pages View Download
125 Materials Laboratory 15B - Factual Report 09-052 Hydraulic Fluid Testing PDF, 36 pages View Download
126 Materials Laboratory 15C - Factual Report 09-050 Flap Actuators PDF, 39 pages View Download
127 Materials Laboratory 15D - Factual Report 09-023 Aileron Control Rod PDF, 4 pages View Download
128 Reports from Parties to the Investigation: Submission Atr PDF, 22 pages View Download
129 Reports from Parties to the Investigation: Submission BEA PDF, 9 pages View Download
130 Reports from Parties to the Investigation: Submission Empire Airlines PDF, 33 pages View Download
131 Reports from Parties to the Investigation: Submission Empire Airlines PDF, 4 pages View Download
132 Reports from Parties to the Investigation: FAA Response to the "No Action Memo" for the Airplane Performance Monitoring System PDF, 3 pages View Download
133 Animation Description Disclaimer PDF, 5 pages View Download
134 Animation in Quicktime Format MOV file Download
135 Public Hearing Opening Presentation PDF, 25 pages View Download
136 Transcript - Public Hearing Day 1 (09/22/09) PDF, 220 pages View Download
137 Transcript - Public Hearing Day 2 (09/23/09) PDF, 252 pages View Download
138 Dgac Special Certification Conditions (2) for the ATR42-320 PDF, 16 pages View Download
139 Board Meeting Animation Description Disclaimer PDF, 5 pages View Download
140 Kinematics Extraction Study PDF, 23 pages View Download

The same docket at the NTSB · documents without a copy here are fetched from the NTSB when you open them.

Connections how this case links to the rest of the register

Aircraft
Place

The whole map of how records connect · these connections as data: /graph/accident/CEN09MA142.json.

The bigger picture in Aviation Analytics: accidents over time since 1982, by model, by phase of flight and conditions, by place and on the map.

Everything on this page comes from the NTSB's public records. The narrative, probable cause and findings are the NTSB's own words; the coded tables behind the report are written out in plain English, with pilots' ages, home towns and medical details left out. The documents and photographs are the NTSB's docket, shown as the NTSB released them. This site's own text does not name anyone involved, its policy at this time. A preliminary report can change; the final report usually follows one to two years later, and the page is refreshed when it does.