The U.S. aircraft register, updated daily
Accidents · NTSB CEN09LA605 · Final report

Piper PA-32-260 accident near Troy, Michigan, September 25, 2009

On September 25, 2009, a Piper PA-32-260, registered N4864S, was substantially damaged in an accident during initial climb near Troy, Michigan (Oakland/Troy Airport). It was a personal flight under general aviation rules (Part 91). 1 person had minor injuries. The weather was visual conditions (good weather).

The NTSB's probable cause their words, unchanged

A loss of engine power during initial climb due to fuel starvation as a result of the pilot's selection of an empty or nearly empty main tank for takeoff.

Source: NTSB aviation accident database, copy made November 2, 2026. Docket and reports at the NTSB.

What the record shows

Date
September 25, 2009 · cases in 2009
Place
Troy, Michigan · Oakland/Troy Airport · cases near this airport · map
Type
Accident
Injuries
1 person had minor injuries.
Weather
visual conditions (good weather)
Aircraft
Piper PA-32-260 · all PA-32-260s on the register
Registration
N4864S · no longer on the register · serial 32-1288
Damage
Substantial damage
Flight
Personal flight · general aviation rules (Part 91)

The NTSB's narrative final · quoted from the NTSB record

The pilot reported that, during his preflight inspection, he verified the fuel quantity and its distribution in the airplane's four fuel tanks. He noted that both inboard (main) fuel tanks were essentially empty and that both outboard (tip) tanks were almost full. He stated that he performed the accident takeoff using fuel from the left tip tank. Before takeoff, he verified that no anomalies existed with the engine operation during the engine check and when he applied power for takeoff. The pilot performed a short-field takeoff with 20 degrees of flaps. The pilot stated that, as the airplane approached the departure end of the runway, the engine experienced a "quick loss of power," which was shortly followed by a sustained loss of power. The pilot immediately performed a forced landing in a parking lot just north of the departure threshold. During the forced landing, the airplane impacted a shopping cart corral and a tree and then slid down an embankment. The right wing tip and tank were sheared off during impact, and a postimpact ground fire ensued at the sheared right wing tip. Postaccident examination of the airplane revealed that the left tip tank contained 4.5 gallons of fuel, about 1/4 of its 17-gallon capacity. (The pilot stated in a postaccident interview that the left tip tank contained 1/2 to 3/4 of its total capacity.) The left main tank contained about 0.6 gallons of fuel. The right main tank did not contain any fuel; however, the fuel drain for that tank was separated from the tank during impact. No fuel was observed leaking from the right main tank, nor was there an odor of leaking fuel. The right tip tank was destroyed by impact damage and the subsequent fire. The cockpit fuel selector was found positioned on the left tip tank. During a postaccident interview with a Federal Aviation Administration inspector, the pilot stated that, after the loss of engine power, he reached for the fuel selector but was unsure of what he did because his attention was diverted by the stall warning light. An operational engine test run revealed no anomalies. The pilot stated that he believed the loss of engine power during initial climb was likely due to fuel starvation, as a result of fuel sloshing in the left tip tank during rotation and initial climb. However, calculations, testing, and operational history showed that the left tip tank would not unport and experience fuel starvation leading to loss of engine power if it contained 4.5 gallons of fuel unless maneuvering during a turning takeoff was extreme. The accident airplane did not experience extreme maneuvers during or immediately after takeoff. Global positioning system (GPS) data downloaded from the pilot's handheld receiver showed that ground maneuvering for the accident takeoff was routine and did not achieve the lateral accelerations necessary to disrupt fuel flow from the left tip tank. Thus, a takeoff using the left tip tank containing 4.5 gallons of fuel would not result in fuel starvation and, ultimately, loss of engine power. Additional testing showed that if a fuel tank was depleted of its useable fuel, the engine would continue to run at takeoff power for an additional 35 to 40 seconds. GPS data for the accident flight showed that the loss of engine power likely occurred 22 to 27 seconds after the takeoff roll was initiated. A takeoff on an empty or nearly empty main tank could result in fuel starvation. The accident takeoff was likely performed on an empty or nearly empty main tank.

The complete narrative as the NTSB published it. The NTSB's docket holds the report as a PDF and any photographs, statements and other documents from the investigation.

The factual record from the NTSB's investigation tables, in plain English

What happened, in order

  1. Preflight or dispatch event during prior to flight
  2. Loss of engine power (partial) during initial climb defining event
  3. Fuel starvation during initial climb
  4. Off-field or emergency landing during emergency descent
  5. Collision with terrain or object (not controlled flight into terrain) during landing (landing roll)
  6. Fire/smoke (post-impact) during post (impact)

The NTSB's findings

  • cause Personnel issues › Action/decision › Action › Incorrect action performance › Pilot
  • cause Aircraft › Fluids/misc hardware › Fluids › Fuel › Fluid level other cases naming the fuel system
  • cause Aircraft › Aircraft systems › Fuel system › (general) › Incorrect use/operation other cases naming the fuel system
  • cause Personnel issues › Task performance › Use of equip/info › Use of equip/system › Pilot

Pilot

  • Certificate: private
  • Ratings: single-engine land; instrument: airplane
  • Flight time: 645 hours in all; 441 in this make and model; 47 in the last 90 days; 16 in the last 30 days; 512 as pilot in command; 0 on instruments
  • Last flight review: November 26, 2008
  • Medical certificate: Class 3 (without waivers/limitations)
  • Seat: left
  • Injury: minor injuries

The aircraft

  • Airframe total time: 3,789 hours
  • Last inspection: annual inspection, February 2, 2009
  • Maximum gross weight: 3,400 lb
  • Seats: 6
  • Landing gear: fixed
  • Engine: Lycoming O-540-E4B5 (piston); 0 hours total
  • Fire on the ground
  • Operator: Galt Zone LLC

The flight

  • Departed from: KVLL Troy MI
  • Destination: KJYM Hillsdale MI
  • Flight plan: not recorded
  • Runway 09, 3,549 ft by 60 ft

Weather at the time

  • Light: night
  • Wind: from 050° at 4 knots
  • Visibility: 10 statute miles
  • Sky: clear
  • Temperature: 64°F (18°C), dew point 48°F (9°C)
  • Altimeter: 30.21 inHg

Injuries

FatalSeriousMinorNone
Flight crew1

Documents from the investigation the NTSB's docket: the evidence folder behind the report

48 documents, released by the NTSB on May 3, 2011. View them here, or download them; the NTSB redacts some personal details before release, and this site shows the NTSB's own titles rather than its file names.

#DocumentWhat it is
1 Pilot/operator Aircraft Accident Report, NTSB Form 6120.1 PDF, 9 pages View Download
2 Additional Pilot Correspondence PDF, 6 pages View Download
3 Troy Police Accident Report, Excerpts PDF, 11 pages View Download
4 Oakland County Airport Incident Report PDF, 2 pages View Download
5 FAA Inspector Statements PDF, 6 pages View Download
6 NTSB Investigator's Airplane Inspection Report PDF, 1 page View Download
7 Airport Layout Information PDF, 2 pages View Download
8 Global Positioning System (GPS) Data Extraction Plot PDF, 2 pages View Download
9 Global Positioning System (GPS) Data Extraction Plot (Altitude Profile) PDF, 1 page View Download
10 Engine Monitoring System Data Download PDF, 74 pages View Download
11 Pilot Flight Log, Excerpts PDF, 2 pages View Download
12 Fuel Consumption Calculations PDF, 5 pages View Download
13 Fueling Information PDF, 1 page View Download
14 Airplane Flight Manual (N4864S, S/n 32-1288) PDF, 9 pages View Download
15 Airplane Owner's Handbook (1970 Model Year), Excerpts PDF, 10 pages View Download
16 Airplane Flight Manual, Revision 7 (Effective Date 11/30/1978) PDF, 9 pages View Download
17 Fuel Selector Placard (P/n 69192, Effective Date 11/30/1978) PDF, 1 page View Download
18 Fuel Selector and Placard (N4864S, S/n 32-1288) -- Overview PDF, 1 page View Download
19 Fuel Selector and Placard (N4864S, S/n 32-1288) -- Cropped/zoomed PDF, 1 page View Download
20 Pilot's Operating Manual (1974-76 Model Years), Excerpts PDF, 21 pages View Download
21 Piper Aircraft Correspondence PDF, 2 pages View Download
22 Propeller Blade Tip "A" PDF, 1 page View Download
23 Propeller Blade Tip "B" PDF, 1 page View Download
24 Digital Video Recordings PDF, 1 page View Download
25 Telecon with Kvll Staff PDF, 2 pages View Download
26 GPS Track Provided by Pilot PDF, 4 pages View Download
27 GPS Data Provided by Pilot spreadsheet Download
28 Lateral Acceleration at Tip Tank PDF, 4 pages View Download
29 1970 PA320260 C Owner's Handbook PDF, 41 pages View Download
30 Excerpts from Various Owner's Manuals PDF, 11 pages View Download
31 Purpose of Owners Handbooks PDF, 3 pages View Download
32 Type Certificate Data Sheet Excerpts PDF, 8 pages View Download
33 Engine Monitoring System Download with Seconds PDF, 81 pages View Download
34 Fuel Burn Calculations PDF, 2 pages View Download
35 Engine Monitoring Data Graphs PDF, 7 pages View Download
36 Unusable Fuel PDF, 3 pages View Download
37 Pilot Proposed Findings PDF, 7 pages View Download
38 Letter Provided by the Pilot PDF, 12 pages View Download
39 Pilot Submission, December 21, 2010 PDF, 5 pages View Download
40 Pilot Submission, May 13, 2011 PDF, 25 pages View Download
41 December 13, 2010 Revisions to Factual PDF, 7 pages View Download
42 5-3-2011 Revisions to Factual PDF, 8 pages View Download
43 FAA Photos PDF, 4 pages View Download
44 Letter Provided by the Pilot, Unredacted Except for Personal Information PDF, 11 pages View Download
45 Telecon with Kvll Airport Manager 051811 PDF, 1 page View Download
46 5-23-2011 Revisions to Factual PDF, 7 pages View Download
47 FAA Inspector Statement, Received 05/23/2011 PDF, 1 page View Download
48 Clearer Copy of Pilot Submission May 13, 2011 PDF, 25 pages View Download

The same docket at the NTSB · documents without a copy here are fetched from the NTSB when you open them.

Connections how this case links to the rest of the register

Aircraft
Place

The whole map of how records connect · these connections as data: /graph/accident/CEN09LA605.json.

The bigger picture in Aviation Analytics: accidents over time since 1982, by model, by phase of flight and conditions, by place and on the map.

Everything on this page comes from the NTSB's public records. The narrative, probable cause and findings are the NTSB's own words; the coded tables behind the report are written out in plain English, with pilots' ages, home towns and medical details left out. The documents and photographs are the NTSB's docket, shown as the NTSB released them. This site's own text does not name anyone involved, its policy at this time. A preliminary report can change; the final report usually follows one to two years later, and the page is refreshed when it does.